不负责任的拒稿意见

热度 13已有 1361 次阅读2011-10-8 15:57 |个人分类:科研信息|

稿件被审稿人拒绝,再也正常不过了。不过有的审稿人实在可恶,写出不负责任的拒稿意见。以下就是几例这样的审稿意见。
 
Although the results seem interesting and correct, the ideas and methods are standard and the results and examples are simple. Hence I do not think this paper deserves to be published in XX.
 
The studied problem is interesting, but, overall, the paper does not reach the high standards of XX.
 
The argument here is standard and not suprizing. the paper does not meet the high standards of XX.
 
Although the paper has some merit it does not contain new ideas. Most of the ideas have appeared in the literature. As a result the paper does not meet the standards of XX.
 
The argument in Section 3 is standard (once the results in Section 2 are derived). Many authors are now presenting results similar to section 2. Unfortunately this paper does not meet the HIGH standards of XX.
2

路过

雷人
1

握手
9

鸡蛋

鲜花

刚表态过的朋友 (12 人)

发表评论 评论 (1 个评论)

回复 lavenderjjt 2012-6-24 11:17
我就被这样据过一次前不久。

关于我们|手机版|订阅|博士家园 ( 沪ICP备15045866号-1 )(沪公网安备沪公网安备 31011702001868号) 

GMT+8, 2024-4-19 11:02 , Processed in 0.092434 second(s), 19 queries .

Powered by Discuz! X3.4

© 2004-2024 博士家园

  • 获赠:邀请码

    博士投稿

    请发电子邮件

    电子邮件

    www@math.org.cn

    在线时间:9:00-16:00

  • 返回顶部